What is Environmental Stress Cracking and ESCR?

The definition of stress cracking according to ASTM D883 is "an external or internal crack in a plastic caused by tensile stresses less than its short-term mechanical strength." This type of cracking typically involves brittle cracking, with little or no ductile drawing of the polymeric material from its adjacent failure surfaces. Slow crack growth is another term commonly used to describe stress cracking. The best known type of slow crack growth is  environmental stress cracking" or ESC. These are instances involving cracking of stressed samples, generally in the presence of surface active wetting agents such as alcohols, soaps, surfactants, or others. The surface-active agents do not chemically attack the polymer nor produce any effect other than microscopically brittle-appearing fractures. In the absence of the surface-active environment, these fractures would not occur in any reasonable period of time under the same stress conditions. These cracks are generally thought to initiate at microscopic imperfections and propagate through the crystalline regions of the polymer structure. The ability of a polymer to resist slow crack growth or environmental stress cracking is known as ESCR. Different polymers exhibit varying degrees of ESCR. Some grades of HDPE have very good resistance against ESC, while some have marginal resilience.


source : You are not allowed to view links. Register or Login

Environmental Stress Cracking (ESC) and ESCR: A Detailed Analysis

1. Introduction
Environmental Stress Cracking (ESC) is a phenomenon that significantly impacts the mechanical integrity and longevity of polymeric materials. The term refers to the development of cracks in a polymer under the influence of tensile stress, even when these stresses are well below the material's short-term mechanical strength. Unlike other types of cracking, ESC is unique because it involves the interaction of a polymer with specific environmental agents, commonly known as surface-active agents. These agents, such as alcohols, detergents, and certain solvents, do not chemically degrade the polymer but facilitate microscopic brittle fractures that lead to crack propagation.

The ability of a polymer to withstand such cracking is referred to as Environmental Stress Crack Resistance (ESCR). ESCR is a critical property in applications where polymers are exposed to combined stress and chemical environments.

2. Definition of Stress Cracking
According to ASTM D883, stress cracking is defined as "an external or internal crack in a plastic caused by tensile stresses less than its short-term mechanical strength." This definition highlights the sub-critical nature of the stresses involved in ESC. Unlike fractures caused by excessive loads, ESC occurs under normal operational loads but requires the presence of an environmental agent that promotes crack initiation and propagation.

Stress cracking typically involves brittle failure, where there is minimal or no plastic deformation before fracture. This type of failure is distinct from ductile failure, which involves significant elongation and necking before rupture.

3. Mechanism of Environmental Stress Cracking
The process of ESC generally involves the following stages:

3.1 Initiation
ESC often begins at microscopic imperfections on the polymer surface, such as notches, scratches, or inherent defects in the material. When a surface-active agent comes into contact with these imperfections, it reduces the surface energy of the polymer, making it more susceptible to crack formation.

3.2 Propagation
Once a crack initiates, it propagates through the material's crystalline regions. Surface-active agents assist in this propagation by reducing the cohesive forces within the polymer chains. The rate of crack propagation is influenced by factors such as the type of polymer, the level of applied stress, and the nature of the environmental agent.

3.3 Failure
Eventually, the crack reaches a critical length where the remaining cross-sectional area of the polymer can no longer support the applied load, leading to catastrophic failure.

4. Factors Affecting ESC
Several factors influence the susceptibility of a polymer to ESC:

4.1 Polymer Structure
- **Crystalline vs. Amorphous Polymers**: Crystalline polymers, such as high-density polyethylene (HDPE) and polypropylene (PP), are more prone to ESC due to their rigid molecular structure. In contrast, amorphous polymers like polystyrene and polycarbonate exhibit better resistance to ESC.
- **Molecular Weight**: Higher molecular weight polymers tend to have better ESCR because of the increased entanglement of polymer chains, which provides greater resistance to crack propagation.

4.2 Environmental Agents
- Surface-active agents such as alcohols, detergents, and certain oils can promote ESC. These agents lower the surface energy of the polymer, facilitating crack initiation and growth.
- The concentration and duration of exposure to these agents also play a crucial role in determining the extent of ESC.

4.3 Stress Level
- ESC occurs under sub-critical tensile stresses. However, higher stress levels accelerate crack propagation and reduce the time to failure.

4.4 Temperature
- Elevated temperatures can either increase or decrease ESCR, depending on the polymer. In some cases, higher temperatures increase the polymer's ductility, thereby reducing the likelihood of brittle failure. In other cases, elevated temperatures accelerate the diffusion of environmental agents into the polymer, promoting ESC.

5. Testing of ESCR
Several standardized tests are used to evaluate the ESCR of polymers:

5.1 ASTM D1693 (Bent Strip Test)
This test involves bending a polymer specimen and immersing it in a surface-active agent. The time taken for cracks to appear is recorded as a measure of the material's ESCR.

5.2 ASTM F1248 (Notched Constant Tensile Load Test)
In this test, a notched polymer specimen is subjected to a constant tensile load in the presence of an environmental agent. The time to failure is used to assess the ESCR.

5.3 Full-Scale Testing
In some cases, full-scale testing of actual products under real-world conditions is performed to assess ESCR. This approach provides the most accurate representation of the material's performance but is time-consuming and expensive.

6. Improving ESCR
Several strategies can be employed to improve the ESCR of polymers:

6.1 Polymer Modification
- **Copolymerization**: Incorporating comonomers can disrupt the crystalline structure of the polymer, increasing its ductility and resistance to ESC.
- **Blending**: Blending the polymer with elastomers or other flexible materials can improve its toughness and ESCR.

6.2 Additives
- Additives such as plasticizers, stabilizers, and antioxidants can enhance the ESCR by modifying the polymer's physical properties or protecting it from environmental degradation.

6.3 Processing Conditions
- Optimizing processing conditions, such as cooling rate and molding pressure, can reduce internal stresses and improve ESCR.

7. Applications and Importance of ESCR
ESCR is a critical property in various applications where polymers are exposed to mechanical stress and chemical environments. Examples include:

7.1 Packaging
- Polymers used in packaging, such as bottles and containers, must have high ESCR to prevent cracking when exposed to detergents, oils, and other chemicals.

7.2 Pipes and Fittings
- Polyethylene pipes used in gas and water distribution systems require excellent ESCR to withstand long-term exposure to environmental stresses and chemicals.

7.3 Automotive Components
- Polymers used in automotive fuel systems, such as fuel tanks and hoses, must resist ESC caused by exposure to fuels and lubricants.

8. Conclusion
Environmental Stress Cracking (ESC) is a significant failure mode in polymeric materials exposed to combined stress and chemical environments. Understanding the factors influencing ESC and implementing strategies to improve ESCR are crucial for ensuring the long-term performance and reliability of polymer-based products. Advances in polymer science, such as the development of high-performance materials and improved testing methods, continue to enhance our ability to design polymers with superior ESCR.

In conclusion, ESC remains a key consideration in the design and selection of polymers for demanding applications. By addressing the underlying mechanisms of ESC and improving material formulations, manufacturers can extend the service life of polymer products and reduce the risk of premature failure.